Wine Spectator 93 points - Elegance and finesse define the pear, melon and honeysuckle flavors, which are lingering and persistent. The creamy texture features a touch of pithy citrus skin, adding to the nuance and complexity. Drink now through 2022.-J.L. (Aug 24 2016)
Vinous 90 points - Energy and focus the two elements that stand out in Shafer’s 2014 Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch. Lemon peel, white pepper and floral notes are some of the signatures. The 2014 is shaping up to be another jewel of a wine from Shafer.
90-93 Points (Oct 2015)